The Generational Comparison: Coming Out vs. Staying Hidden

    Fun Home, the “Family Tragicomic,” was introduced to us with the preface of the author, Alison Bechdel, and her queer identity. We’re made aware from the very first chapter that she ‘shared’ with her father this distinctiveness, with one key difference we later find out: The culture of Alison’s time made coming out a possible reality for her, while quite the opposite was the reality for her father. Their experiences with their sexuality demonstrate how important the generational context shapes the story of the Bechdels. 

    Alison, our author and main protagonist of the book, goes through a journey of self-discovery during a time that provided more space for this sort of exploration that her father, being of the previous generation, was not afforded the luxury of. She, like her father, turns to literature as a means of navigating her individuality, finding pieces of herself in the works she reads. She actively seeks out ways to define what she feels and find words to further understand her character (through various books that come up) and the relationships she has with others (I think of the consistent metaphors throughout the novel as a strong example, especially when used to describe her relationship with her father). There’s also notability in her choosing to come out as a deliberate act, something that could be accepted living in a period of transition. The fact that Alison was able to come out says a lot about the strength and courage of her character as well, contrasted by the tragic story of her father. 

    While many of Bruce Bechdel’s life choices feel inexcusable, it’s understood by the readers that his entire life had been defined by concealment. This was concealment of his identity, his self-expression (tying back to him cross-dressing), and additionally the loss of the freedom that came with being open and accepting about who you are, not only to yourself but to the world around you. His concealment hurt in more ways than one, affecting more than just him. Selfishly, his sexuality and fixation on younger men also hurt those he arguably groomed, as well as his wife, and eventually, his family. Bruce grew up in a time and place where homosexuality was far less accepted than in the time period Alison’s story takes place in, and from that, he chose to live a life focused on appearance. Rather than coming out like his daughter and accepting his sense of self, he had chosen to hide behind meticulously created facades meant to resemble everything he was supposed to be and do. It’s telling that the cover of the graphic novel includes the heavily posed photo of the Bechdel family taken by Bruce, portraying them as that ‘picture perfect’ family, and that Alison had to find out about her dad not through him but through her mother. By focusing on her father’s story alongside hers, Bechdel calls attention to how societal circumstances impact a person’s ability to live authentically, and from that, how they’re made to live their life. 

    Alison’s circumstances afforded her the opportunity to be honest with herself and be expressive, while Bruce’s early life taught him that a life of openness and freedom wasn’t in the cards for him.

Comments

  1. SaifMarch 22, 2026 at 8:18 PM


    Hi Shanna, I really enjoyed how you focused on the generational differences between Alison and Bruce and used that to show how deeply their identities were shaped by the time periods they lived in. Your point about literature serving as a path to self-understanding for Alison, while Bruce is defined by secrecy and performance, was especially insightful and added a layer of depth to your analysis. I do wonder, though, if you think Alison had provided too much sympathy for Bruce’s harm in society even though the social pressures had definitely persuaded him to commit those crimes. Overall, fantastic job on your blog post!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Holden Caufield as a Male SA Victim

  “Boy, I was shaking like a madman. I was sweating, too. When something perverty like that happens, I start sweating like a bastard. That kind of stuff’s happened to me about twenty times since I was a kid. I can’t stand it,” (Salinger, 251). J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye is a renowned coming-of-age novel focused on the story of Holden Caulfield and his daily endeavours following his expulsion from Pencey Prep. The novel is told in a first-person narrative by Holden, giving the readers a unique look into his inner monologue. We get well acquainted with him throughout the book— his way of thinking, what he likes, what he dislikes (though he has considerably more dislikes than likes). He goes off into tangents very easily about what he witnesses in things and people. Notably though, Holden doesn’t talk about himself as much as you’d assume, seeing that the story is told from his perspective. I feel that one of the most important scenes in the book, if not the most import...
Read more

How Mental Health Makes it Difficult to “Choose Sides” in The Bell Jar

               According to the World Health Organization, more than one billion people are currently living with mental health disorders, meaning that it affects one out of every eight people. Nowadays, mental health is more often brought up in conversation and addressed rather than stigmatized. With these modern ideas, when going back to read books like The Bell Jar, mental illness complicates the idea of “choosing sides” for the reader, making it harder to pick where our empathy and sympathies lie within the characters of the novel (Esther Greenwood, Mrs. Greenwood, Dodo Conway, etc.)  Esther’s Clinical/Psychotic Depression shapes her narration throughout the book, shadowing over the people she describes rather harshly. Her state makes it hard to be angry at how she treats those around her, even when they’re kind-hearted or people close to her. At the same time, you still really do sympathize with the people she speaks of as they’re o...
Read more